• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Shady Oak Primary School

  • What We Do
    • Connection
    • Communication
    • Collaboration
    • Creativity
    • Critical Thinking
    • Problem Solving
  • Who We Are
    • Teachers
    • Leadership
  • How We Do It
    • Culture
    • Child-centered Learning
    • Participatory Learning
    • Skills-focused Learning
    • Play-based Learning
  • Our School
    • Admissions Overview
    • School Forms
    • Tab Studio
  • Calendar
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
    • Podcast
  • Events
  • PTA
AGREEING TO DISAGREE: GOOD IDEA OR BAD?

AGREEING TO DISAGREE: GOOD IDEA OR BAD?

AGREEING TO DISAGREE: GOOD IDEA OR BAD?

“I guess we’ll just have to agree to disagree” is a phrase commonly heard when an argument reaches impasse. It’s certainly better than holding grudges, or dragging out a fight indefinitely. But is “agreeing to disagree” a legitimate acknowledgment of legitimate differences of opinion? Or is it a cop-out to avoid the work of seeking a true win-win situation?

ShadyOak-arguement

Every difference of opinion has to be settled on its own merits, and it often does happen that the best thing to do is drop the subject in a spirit of mutual respect. However, agreeing to disagree may do more harm than good if:

One Party Holds All the Advantage

For some people, particularly authority figures, “Let’s agree to disagree” is code language for “The subject is closed. You don’t have to believe what I say, but you have to do what I say.” Those on the receiving end understandably resent this, especially if they feel they haven’t been given a fair hearing.

This approach is common with parents who resent their children’s independent thinking. Be sure you’ve fully considered their point of view before “agreeing to disagree.”

ShadyOak-Mother-scolding-child

There Are Likely to Be Repercussions

If any of the following apply, it’s asking for trouble to give each side implicit permission to do things his or her way:

The disagreement involves a joint project, from building a bridge to planning a family vacation, where results would be chaotic if different people approached by different paths.

A deeper, serious issue is left unresolved. Where real injustice or danger is involved, cutting off the discussion prematurely is bottling up trouble to explode in the future.

Hard feelings continue to fester. If either or both sides hold a grudge, you haven’t really agreed to disagree. Don’t go away mad yourself, and don’t leave harsh words hanging in the air. (Test question: are you waiting for the day you can say, “I told you so”?)

Where disagreement is really harsh, an outside arbitrator may be necessary. If you find yourself in this position (even if just to decide which of your children really went first last time), don’t be so eager to “get this settled” that either party feels cheated out of an objective hearing.

Anyone Is Being Just Plain Lazy

ShadyOak-Arguing-Couple

The principle of “not settling it before it’s settled” applies equally to arbitrators and participants. Sometimes there’s no obvious danger of power plays or repercussions, yet it’s still a bad idea to say, “Let’s just agree to disagree.” Are you harboring any secret condescension toward the other party? Do you want to avoid thinking about the larger issues? Is your pride determined not to modify your opinion, no matter what? In that case, even if the immediate disagreement has no repercussions, you’re cheating yourself out of a chance to grow and develop.

vinjeta-ispod-naslova

Disagreements are inevitable, and some aren’t worth making a big deal over. But they should never be allowed to interfere with the greater good of nurturing mutual respect.

vinjeta-ispod-naslova
ShadyOak-Xmassadchild

COULD YOUR CHILD HAVE MEDICAL DEPRESSION? SYMPTOMS TO BE AWARE OF

By delder | February 19, 2021
ShadyOak-Thinking-Parent

AM I LOSING MY MIND?

By delder | February 19, 2021
paranoid-mom

DON’T GET PARANOID: HOW PARENTS CAN FIND RELIABLE INFORMATION

By delder | February 19, 2021
Shady Oak - frustrated teacher

A TEACHER’S GUIDE TO STAYING CALM AMIDST CHAOS

By delder | February 19, 2021
Happy kid enjoying arts and crafts painting with his hands

FIVE SECRETS OF JOYFUL LIVING

By delder | February 19, 2021
The sun is setting on the age of innocence.

FIVE SECRETS OF CONFIDENT LIVING

By delder | February 18, 2021
Disappointed-Parent

DISCONNECT YOUR PANIC BUTTONS

By delder | February 18, 2021
Angry-parent

A PARENT’S GUIDE TO STAYING CALM AMIDST CHAOS

By delder | February 11, 2021
smile

WAYS YOUR FAMILY CAN PROMOTE PEACE ON EARTH

By delder | January 2, 2021
Shady Oaks - Sheltered Kid

WHEN THE KIDS ARE HOME, Part 2

By delder | December 28, 2020

Today's affirmation:
"I CARE ENOUGH TO TRANSFORM THE GOOD INTO THE GREAT"

We are located at:
600 Main Street
Richmond, TX 77469
Tel: (281) 344-1291
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2021 Shady Oak Primary School, All Rights Reserved. • Email • Fine Print

Shady Oak Am I Doing It Right
Shady Oak Children and Families Enjoying Life
Shady Oak Raising Emotionally and Physically Healthy Children
Shady Oak Raising Positive Confident and Effective Children
Shady Oak Raising Your Children to Be Responsible
Shady Oak Success Strategies for Teachers